A Ferrovia de Lages está no mapa da nova concessão, mas não no plano de obras, e a ANTT prorrogou o prazo para reclamar até 30 de setembro — Insubornavel

The Lages Railway is on the map of the new concession, but not in the works plan, and ANTT extended the claim deadline until August 25th.

ماخذ: Insubornavel
از Benito Juarez07/08/2026 às 20:40666 مشاہدات
Cabeçalho do ofício com que o Ministério Público Federal — MPF escreveu, em 27 de fevereiro de 2026, às autoridades responsáveis pela Ferrovia Malha Sul, no dia em que o contrato de concessão completou 29 anos. Assinado por sete procuradores, entre eles Fernando de Almeida Martins, citado adiante.
Cabeçalho do ofício com que o Ministério Público Federal — MPF escreveu, em 27 de fevereiro de 2026, às autoridades responsáveis pela Ferrovia Malha Sul, no dia em que o contrato de concessão completou 29 anos. Assinado por sete procuradores, entre eles Fernando de Almeida Martins, citado adiante.
Reprodução: Ofício Circular GAB1/PRM/SA n.º 01/2026, Procuradoria da República em Santo Ângelo (RS) — Inquérito Civil n.º 1.29.010.000227/2020-14. / Ministério Público Federal

The National Land Transportation Agency - ANTT is preparing the contract that will govern, for the next thirty years, the railway that crosses the Catarinense Mountains.And the deadline for any citizen to provide feedback on the text ends on Monday, August 10, 2026, at 11:59 PM. The Unyielding downloaded and reviewed the twenty-four documents submitted to...public consultationThe document includes approximately 2.3 gigabytes of minutes, notebooks, and studies. The 292.76 km (182 miles) stretch between Mafra and Lages, currently without train service, is described in the object of the future concession, but it does not appear in the mandatory investment plan, which is the part of the contract where projects are given a deadline, target, and budget.

What's at stake:The Mafra to Lages line on the South Main Trunk is at a standstill, impacting the economy: without trains, cargo is transported entirely by truck, with freight costs approximately 20% higher and an additional 80-100 trucks per week, according to client reports registered by the Ministry of Transport. This leads to higher prices for goods and services, traffic congestion, and wear on highways. The ANTT is finalizing the contract text for the next thirty years, and the public hearing is the main formal opportunity to influence before that. The return of trains could lower cargo costs and ease roads, depending on demand and rates. Passenger transport, which the line previously had and would benefit tourism, would depend on separate projects and authorization: this concession is for cargo.

This is the first in a series: the report presents here what the documents say, what each party has already declared publicly about the case in a hearing at the Chamber of Deputies, how to contribute to the consultation before it closes, and where to consult each cited document, all preserved and available for verification.

Deadline:Contributions to Public Hearing No. 11/2026 are accepted untilMonday, August 10, 2026, 11:59 PMvia theParticipANTT system. After this date, ANTT consolidates the statements and proceeds to the final version of the tender documents and contracts.Update (Aug. 17, 2026):ANTT extended the contribution deadline untilAugust 25, 2026.

What is at stake?

The current contract for the South Network, operated by Rumo since 2016 and stemming from the 1990s concession, is nearing its end. To replace it, the Union will...It proposes to divide the network into three independent lots.Paraná Corridor - Santa Catarina, Rio Grande Corridor and Mercosur Corridor, also referred to as the Interstate Corridor in technical documents. Each lot will have its own tender and contract, with a term of thirty years from assumption.

Mafra and Lages are located in the Mercosur Corridor.Bidding document outlineIt describes the lot, item 1.2.3 on page 10, as the network that "starts from Mafra (SC), (...) crosses the state of Santa Catarina and reaches Rio Grande do Sul, continuing until Roca Sales (RS)", totaling 1,865.78 km.

Imagem de satélite do planalto catarinense com o traçado da Ferrovia marcado em vermelho, de Mafra, ao norte, até Lages e Capão Alto, ao sul, com as cidades assinaladas.
The 292.76 km between Mafra and Lages in a 2026 satellite image: the red line is the railway route, and the dots are the cities it passes through.
Image: Copernicus Sentinel-2, twelve scenes from April to August 2026 (modified Copernicus Sentinel data, 2026). Rail Trace:OpenStreetMap, contributors (ODbL).
Prédio da antiga estação ferroviária de Mafra, em Santa Catarina, fotografado em 2009.
Mafra station in 2009. From this point the Mercosul Corridor starts, according to item 1.2.3 of the tender minute.
Photo: Swendt, 2009, public domain, viaWikimedia Commons.
Página 10 da minuta de edital da ANTT, com o item 1.2.3 descrevendo o Lote C — Corredor Mercosul a partir de Mafra (SC)
Tender minute, item 1.2.3, page 10: Lot C - Mercosul Corridor starts "from Mafra (SC)" and reaches Roca Sales (RS).
Reproduction: ANTT - Public Hearing No. 11/2026.Read the full minute..

This is the section whose interruption the ANTT considered irregular: according toInformative Note No. 65/2025 from the Ministry of Transportation, forwarded to the Chamber of Deputies in response to Information Request No. 3834/2025, the Ministry was not previously notified of the stop; the National Association of Cargo Transport Users - ANUT filed a complaint; Raízen and Vibra Energia expressed interest in continuing fuel transport; and the section moved, before the 2024 floods, from 8,000 to 10,000 tons per month. The ANTT considered that the stoppage violated Resolution ANTT No. 5,945, imposed a fine, and notified Rumo to resume operations within thirty days. Customers of the section reported to the ANTT, and the same note records their report, that transferring the load to the road increased road freight by about 20%. By the equivalence adopted in the document itself, where each tank car corresponds to two or two and a half tank trucks, the change added from 80 to 100 trucks per week to the region's highways.

Locomotiva vermelha da América Latina Logística parada junto ao prédio da estação de Lages, com a composição atrás.
Composition of América Latina Logística - ALL, the previous concessionaire, at Lages station in April 2004, when there was still a train on the section.
Photo: Carlos Latuff, April 2004, reproduced with written authorization from the author. Copy hosted atBrazilian Railway Stations, by Ralph Mennucci Giesbrecht.

The line was not born from private initiative: the section between Mafra and Lages was constructed between 1963 and 1965 by2nd Railway BattalionThe South Main Line project was completed in 1968 with the installation of the last steel beam at kilometer 349, 36 kilometers south of Lages, where a monument now stands featuring the insignia of the railway battalions that built it. Passenger transport continued until 1978, and the mixed train service—carrying both cargo and passengers in the same train—ran until 1983.

Monumento de concreto com duas barras de trilho fixadas no topo e as insígnias dos batalhões ferroviários, em campo aberto.
The monument at kilometer 349, south of Lages, marks the point where the last steel beam of the South Main Stem was installed in 1968.
Photo: Ministry of Defense, October 15, 2020, via [...]Text: Wikimedia CommonsText: Under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 license.

2. What do the documents in review say?

The text: "O [The] jornal 'O Estado de S. Paulo' completa 90 anos de fundação em 2023, celebrando uma história rica em jornalismo e influência na mídia brasileira."Obligation NotebookIt is Annex 1 of the contract and the document that turns the alignment into a work obligation. The one for the Interstate Corridor has forty pages, and not once does the word "Mafra" appear. "Lages" appears twice, always within the expression "Section between Roca Sales – Lages," which designates the southern tip affected by the floods—item 4.3 of the same notebook limits these works to the damages caused "to federal railway assets in the state of Rio Grande do Sul" by the calamity in May 2024.

The mandatory investments in infrastructure for the corridor are four, all located in Rio Grande do Sul, with deadlines and costs defined: Roca Sales - General Luz, Industrial Yard - General Luz, Tigre - Cacequi, and Passo Fundo - Guaporé. The recovery of climate damage, with a three-year deadline, only reaches Lages partially through the south: "In 89.06 km out of the 295 km stretch between Roca Sales - Lages," states item 4.3.1 on page 13.

Página 13 do Caderno de Obrigações do Corredor Interestadual, com o item 4.3.1 sobre a recuperação de 89,06 km dos 295 km do trecho Roca Sales – Lages
State Highway Obligation Book, page 13: The climate damage recovery reaches "89.06 km out of the 295 km stretch between Roca Sales - Lages," at the southern tip of Rio Grande do Sul; Mafra is not mentioned in the document.
Reproduction: ANTT - Public Hearing No. 11/2026.Read the complete section..

The Obligations Notebook states what will be mandatory to do. TheEngineering Studywhich provides the basis for modeling, produced by the Nova Malha Sul Consortium, demonstrates how the Catarinense segment was evaluated. The study divides the network into clusters, which are sets of segments examined in blocks, and Mafra - Lages is cluster INTE_04. In Table 8-2, pages 74 and 75, the twelve lines of this cluster repeat the same observation about the route, which is the set of tracks, sleepers, and bed where the train passes:

The route already has favorable physical conditions, not justifying immediate interventions.

Página 74 do Estudo de Engenharia do Corredor Interestadual, Tabela 8-2, com a observação de que a via já apresenta condições físicas favoráveis
Engineering Study, Table 8-2, page 74: the observation "The route already has favorable physical conditions" repeats in the lines of cluster INTE_04, the Mafra - Lages segment.
Reproduction: ANTT / Nova Malha Sul Consortium — Public Hearing No. 11/2026.Read the complete study.

The same study projects cargo on the segment over the thirty-year concession period, from 1.17 million tons in 2027 to 1.91 million in 2056, and ranks it fifth among fourteen subgroups in a relevance indicator. However, INTE_04 does not appear in the budget and schedule tables, and there is no cost sheet for it among those attached to the study.

MeanwhileOperational StudyAnother document in the same package describes the segment differently. In the inter-station spreadsheet, eight out of twelve segments are marked as "Interrupted," and the first one, from Mafra to Itaiópolis, has the justification phrase "Currently non-operational segment" with installed capacity equal to zero.

Finally, thecontract minutestates, in clause 3.2.5 on page 15, that the future concessionaire may "request the return or deactivation of the Concession Assets related to idle or uneconomical railway segments." The criterion for characterizing a segment as uneconomical is in the following item and is alternative: it is sufficient, among other hypotheses, for "the absence of commercial traffic."

Página 15 da minuta de contrato do Corredor Mercosul, cláusula 3.2.5, sobre devolução ou desativação de trechos ociosos ou antieconômicos
Corredor Mercosul contract minute, clause 3.2.5, page 15: the future concessionaire may request the return of segments "idle or uneconomical," and "the absence of commercial traffic" is enough as a criterion.
Reproduction: ANTT — Public Hearing No. 11/2026.Read the complete contract.
Why does this matter to those who live in the Serra?The map outlines what the future concessionaire will receive. The works plan details what they must do, by when, and with how much money. Mafra – Lages is on the map but not in the plan. Without a scheduled work, the train only returns if the company wants it to. And, as long as the section remains without a train, the contract itself allows them to request its permanent return.

3. What do the parties say?

At a public hearing of the Committee on Transportation and Infrastructure of the Chamber of Deputies on April 7, 2026, speakers addressed the South Grid, including the concessionaire, ANTT (National Agency for Transport Regulation), the Federal Public Ministry - MPF, users, and workers. The positions are as follows:Minutes of the session..

The concessionaire:Ticiano Augusto Callai Bragatto, who represented Rumo Malha Sul, attributed the shrinking of the network to unfulfilled load forecasts since the 1990s bid and the end in 1997 of the rule requiring shippers to contract rail for hazardous materials. He stated that this is "the reason these segments are no longer economically viable, especially with the regulatory burden present," and that "in the last 10 years, we have not seen a significant reduction in the network, except for the climate disaster in May 2024." He also presented the numbers the company claims to have invested: R$ 17.8 billion over 29 years across the three concessionaires who operated the network, more than half of which was invested in the last decade, with a cash burn of approximately R$ 320 million per year and controller investments exceeding R$ 5 billion.

The Federal Public Ministry:Fernando de Almeida Martins, Regional Republic Attorney, who represented the General Attorney's Office, stated that "the South Mesh has over 7,000 kilometers, of which two-thirds to three-quarters are currently abandoned," and expressed surprise at the proposal for fragmentation. Regarding Santa Catarina, he was specific, and the cut-out section covers this report: with the proposed design, he said, "eradication will not reach 100% due to the São Francisco do Sul Port," so whoever takes over the network "will save that piece, but the rest, or 90%, will also go." This is an institutional statement at a parliamentary hearing, not a judicial decision: none of the body's procedures on the matter have led to a conviction.

Trecho da página 38 do Diário Eletrônico do Ministério Público Federal de 11 de dezembro de 2025, com a portaria que converteu o procedimento preparatório em inquérito civil sobre o abandono da linha férrea em Mafra.
MPF Electronic Diary of December 11, 2025, page 38: the decree that initiated the Civil Inquiry into the "poor maintenance and abandonment of buildings and the railway line" in Mafra, within the Rumo South Mesh concession area.
Reproduction: MPF Electronic Diary No. 230/2025, Extralegal, December 11, 2025.

The users:Luis Henrique Teixeira Baldez, President of ANUT, the entity that reported the halt, responded to the argument of lack of demand by reversing the cause-and-effect order: "Insecurity leads immediately for companies to seek alternatives, migrating to road transport. (...) They say: 'No, but there is no demand.' It's clear that there isn't, because the demand that was trying to be allocated to that mode of transport goes elsewhere." He opposed fragmentation with an arithmetic argument ("I have a financially viable mesh and two financially inviable ones") and maintained that with the proposed design, "we are declaring that we will eradicate railway lines in Santa Catarina and Rio Grande do Sul."

The workers:João Edacir Calegari Morais, President of the Railway Workers' Union of Rio Grande do Sul - Sindifergs, attributed the trains' slow speed to material causes: "What happens is that trains run at 10 or 15 kilometers per hour due to a lack of investment in infrastructure."

There is also an ongoing legal dispute: the State of Santa Catarina filed Common Procedure No. 5024423-10.2026.4.04.7200, at the 3rd Federal Court in Florianópolis, to suspend this public hearing.The preliminary injunction was denied on July 15, 2026.However, the court ordered the Union and ANTT to justify the alleged lack of access by the state and the Southern Development and Integration Council (Codesul) to the technical studies.

If the case has reached this point with documentation, it is due to identifiable actions: the formal complaint from ANUT, chaired by Luis Henrique Teixeira Baldez; the public statement by Regional Prosecutor Fernando de Almeida Martins; the alert from Sindifergs president João Edacir Calegari Morais on underinvestment; Request for Information No. 3834/2025 from the Committee on Transportation and Highways in the Chamber of Deputies, which forced the Ministry of Transport to put the numbers on paper; the state of Santa Catarina's trip to federal court; and the MPF's civil inquiry in Mafra regarding the line and buildings' maintenance.

Vista da Coxilha Rica com o viaduto ferroviário sobre o Rio Tatetos ao centro, entre Lages e Capão Alto, sem trem.
The railway viaduct over the Tatetos River, in Rica Valley, between Lages and Capão Alto, in May 2020: the track crosses the valley on pillars, without a train.
Photo: Gibbneckel, May 2, 2020, under licenseCreative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0viaWikimedia CommonsWithout any cuts or editing.

4. How to contribute, step by step

Anyone can contribute, and the contribution will be recorded in the process: the system is ParticipANTT, and the event is Public Hearing No. 11/2026.

  1. Openhttps://participantt.antt.gov.br/events?CodigoAudiencia=674And register or log in, in the top left corner of the page.
  2. On the tabContributeChoose the topic corresponding to the document you want to comment on: there are thirty topics, one per document or set of devices, and the contribution yields more when released under the right topic, rather than all in one field. Be mindful of the name: no topic is called "Interstate Corridor", which is how technical files refer to the Mercosul Corridor; on the screen, the topics in this batch are "Mercosul Corridor Obligations Notebook", "Mercosul Corridor Contract Draft" and so forth.
  3. Indicate the exact device (e.g., "Mercosul Corridor Obligations Notebook, Appendix A, item 4.2"), state whether the proposal is for inclusion, alteration, suppression or correction, write down the suggested text and justification.
  4. Keep the protocol proof: it serves as evidence that the point was raised before ANTT's decision, and it is useful for tracking responses and making representations to control bodies.
  5. Those who prefer speaking over writing can consult, within the same system, Public Hearing Procedures No. 11/2026, which outline rules for statements.

Four points suggested by the reading of the documents for those who want to contribute on the Catarinense section: request the inclusion of a Mafra – Lages subgroup in Appendix A of the Obligations Notebook, with extension, deadline, cost and mandatory start date; request correction of item 1.1 of this notebook, which applies to the "Concessionaire of 'Paraná - Santa Catarina' Railway"; request that the return of the section for "absence of commercial traffic" not apply when the absence of trains resulted from an interruption established in a process by ANTT itself; and request a verifiable obligation for periodic circulation of line records and patrimonial surveillance on a section without traffic, with periodic documentary proof.

5. Where to consult the documents

Every document cited in this report was downloaded, verified, and preserved with origin registration, size, date and time of collection, and SHA-256 verification code, which allows anyone to confirm that the file has not been altered since. The ten main documents are published, along with their verification codes, on theTronco Sul ArchiveThe rest of the collection, with 108 documents, can be requested through the page.Suggest a Topic.

Key documents cited and what each one brings
DocumentWhat it brings
Draft tender document for the three corridorsDescription of lots; Mafra in the object of the Mercosul Corridor, p. 10
Draft contract for the Mercosul CorridorClause 3.2.5, return of idle or anti-economic sections, pp. 15 and 16
Obligatory Runner's HandbookMandatory investment plan; absence of Mafra – Lages
Engineering Study of the Interstate CorridorRoad diagnosis, projected load, and the statement about favorable physical conditions
Operational Study, Volume IInter-pavement sheet with interrupted segments
Letter No. 1714/2025/ASPAR/GM and Informative Note No. 65/2025Fine, order to retake, freight and additional trucks
Transcription notes from the Chamber, April 7, 2026Protests from Rumo, ANTT, MPF, ANUT, and Sindifergs

The original addresses for each item are in the Sources section at the end, and the preserved copy by Insubornável is for the case that the document goes offline or is replaced, which is common in public consultation, and to allow comparison between versions.

6. What's next?

The text provided is incomplete, so here is the translation based on what was given: "The article:"Second part of this seriesAlready published, the newspaper article reads the contract minute clause by clause and shows that the future concessionaire will have the duty to preserve the 292.76 km between Mafra and Lages, but will not have a date to put a train into operation there - and that the contract provides for the return of the section precisely because there is no train.

This investigation continues, and the upcoming sections will address what is still unresolved: the liability of the concession that is ending and who pays for recovery; what the railway corridor generates through uses other than trains; the precedent of concessions from the same group rescinded in Argentina in 2013; and how the railway infrastructure appears, or does not appear, in Brazilian doctrine on the protection of critical infrastructures.

The public response remains pending regarding the sanctioning process number and the infraction report against the concessionaire, the value and status of the fine, theinspection reports scheduled for April and August 2025on the stretch and the date of the last commercial circulation between Mafra and Lages. Insubornável will forward these questions to Rumo, ANTT, the Ministry of Transportation, and the National Department of Transport Infrastructure - DNIT, with a deadline and delivery record, and will publish the answers in full or, if none are provided, the date, channel, questions, and granted deadline.

Anyone with a document, a dated photograph of the stretch, communication received from the concessionaire, or information about the last train circulation between Mafra and Lages can reach out to the reporting team via the pageSuggest a Topicor by emailnewsroom@insubornavel.com.

7. To explore: the sources, with notes

7.1 Official documents and public records

7.2 Who monitors and defends the Railway

  • ANUT — National Association of Freight Transport Users, author of the complaint about the shutdown of the section.https://anut.org.br/ The website maintains an open social participation framework, including this audience, and a railway fare simulator.
  • ABPF — Brazilian Association for Railway Preservation, a non-profit civil entity dedicated to railroad heritage.https://www.abpf.com.br/ It keeps a dynamic museum and tourist train inRio Negrinho, a town next to Mafra.
  • Rail Stations of Brazil, by Ralph Mennucci Giesbrecht — a page on the South Main Trunk, station by station, from Mafra to General Luz.https://www.estacoesferroviarias.com.br/sc_troncosul/tronco_sul.htm History of the Mafra-Lajes line: built between 1963 and 1965 by the 2nd Railway Battalion, with passenger service until 1978.
  • "Pilgrimage on the South Trunk", by Elvis Pfützenreuter — field report on the Mafra–Itaiópolis section, featuring station photos and notes on the 37 tunnels in Santa Catarina.https://epxx.co/artigos/troncosul.html The author grants permission to quote excerpts with reference to the author and the source.
  • AMURC — Association of Municipalities of the Contestado Region, which submitted a technical contribution dedicated to the Mafra–Lages section at this hearing.https://participantt.antt.gov.br/events?CodigoAudiencia=674 Requests full maintenance of the section, protection clauses for assets, prohibition of non-indemnized return, use by tourist trains and independent operators, and cooperation with the Brazilian Army for recovery studies.
  • AMPLANORTE — Association of Municipalities of the Northern Catarinense Plateau, headquartered in Mafra, which also sent letters to the hearing.https://www.amplanorte.org.br/ The two associations are, so far, the institutional actors who defend the stretch within the ANTT process.
  • Carlos Latuff - photographer and cartoonist, author of the record of the Lages station in April 2004.https://ferroviasdobrasil.blogspot.com/ He authorized in writing, on August 7, 2026, the reproduction of the photographs used in this report.

Produced with Claude Fable 5 (Anthropic, AI), under the direction and responsibility of Benito Juarez.

Style note - The Unyielding writes with the reverential uppercase of Classical Portuguese and extends it to all office preceded by name: the Engineer, the Anthropologist, the Shine-maker - at the same level as the Governor.

اپ ڈیٹ کیا گیا 24/08/2026 às 14:54

مواد انگریزی میں دکھایا جا رہا ہے — اس زبان میں خودکار ترجمہ ابھی دستیاب نہیں ہے۔

کیا یہ خبر مفید تھی؟

تبصرے 0

Seja o primeiro a contribuir com o debate.

Difunda suas informações e promova seu argumento

مفید معلومات شیئر کرنے میں ہچکچاہٹ نہ کریں۔

بحث میں حصہ لینے کے لیے، لاگ ان کریں یا مفت اکاؤنٹ بنائیں۔